Right so currently...
1: Ross
2: Jamie.
Jamie, What I have found form observing other games is that no-one gets accused initially due to lack of evidence, but as the game progresses you may start to suspect people who might have not said anything during the game, or who have accused someone twice in a row or who may have accused anyone right from the start.
It also helps if the Doctor saves someone or the trapper manages to trap someone, which I will announce each turn, or if the insomniac is used they will report that they heard someone, or the Sheriff might post here and tell the name of someone who is mafia.
6 more to fill at least. I can't play since I need to be the game master