Originally Posted by scrotnig
Don't feel uninspired. For starters, it's great he took the time to evaluate it at all, and actually the fact that that he gave it a proper critical overview rather than just saying "yeah it's nice" is quite a tribute to you. He clearly takes your efforts seriously.
|
Well, don't misunderstand me. I'm feeling uninspired just because I haven't had any particular bursts of inspiration lately -- not because of Murray's comments! I agree, Murray's been good to me and it's nice of him to help out.
Originally Posted by scrotnig
It doesn't need starting from scratch. Maybe take what he says on board. Or just some of it. Or none of it! He's giving you his opinion, what he likes and what he thinks works does not have to be exactly the same as what you like and what you think works.
|
I understand that, however obviously Murray's views are important because for one thing, my mix was based on his theme, and for another, I did send him the theme, didn't I?
And as far as starting over, I find it helpful to start things over when they don't work. Starting over for me does not mean throwing away a lot of work. It just means a fresh start and a new beginning, which is often the most helpful thing I can do.
Originally Posted by scrotnig
Sure I can understand you're disappointed - but don't take it personally. He clearly respects your efforts or he wouldn't bother with such an honest, if not that complimentary, appraisal.
|
I'm not taking it personally. In fact, Murray thought I took his criticism very well (based on my response). He's actually been giving me some good advice lately (especially after the incident that took place earlier this year, it seems we're beginning to move past that finally). He's being a great help and I appreciate it.