Originally Posted by Ronnie Rowlands
Well I haven't seen any, all I've seen is pretty much 'it's shit because RTD wrote it," and then the usual GTFO stuff. And, Kody, if you're admitting you have liked his episodes, but say this is weak, why are you suddenly all for getting rid of him? Should we get rid of all writers who write a bad episode once in a while?
|
Out of the 26 episodes he's wrote, I've enjoyed about 8-9 of them, if that.
When he writes bad ones, such as this and the season ending for last year, they're spectacularly bad and feel downright insulting to me. So yes, while he can write good the bad far outweighs it, in my opinion.
As for. "I haven't seen any", I haven't seen any full lists from people like Rat or such with all the highlights of the episode either. Just random mentions of the bits you all liked. So go ahead and write out a big list or proper review of why it's so amazing and I'll do the same with my views, alright?
These discussion threads usually seem to lack such reviews or in depth thoughts.
Originally Posted by Ronnie Rowlands
I'm sorry, but I simply cannot see a picture of Patrick Stewart giving someone the finger as a reason why someone dislikes an episode.
|
This, is meant to be a 'joke'.
http://www.google.com/search?source=...=Google+Search
If you want a serious list of reasons, I'd expect the same from someone who is saying this is some of the best television ever.
